Bug #948: fix duplicated rows in view_full_occurrence_individual - BIEN 3 - NCEAS Projects

Bug #948

Updated by Aaron Marcuse-Kubitza over 9 years ago

h3. issue 

 "from Brody":mailto:brody.sandelATbiology.au.dk?Brody_Sandel.2014-8-22-9:43PT: 

 > SELECT * FROM view_full_occurrence_individual WHERE datasource = 
 > 'VegBank' AND plot_name = 'CO081202XY04' 
 > ; 
 >  
 > returns two lines with "Lupinus argenteus". Those lines appear to be complete duplicates, except for the last field (taxonobservation_id) which is 1230 for one and 1231 for the next. Both lines show cover_percent of 2. 
 >  
 > Looking at VegBank (http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/observation_comprehensive.jsp?view=comprehensive&entity=observation&wparam=42558&strata2Show=1&params=42558&placeholder=), I see a single entry of Lupinus argenteus, with a cover of 2%. 
 >  
 > There's a similar situation for Quercus gambelii in this particular plot. 

 h3. status 

 p(. the problem is in the TNRS table, which at one point was is allowing the same input name to be scrubbed multiple times (and therefore to have multiple best-match entries). the duplicate scrubbing no longer happens (@make scrub@ does not rescrub any names), so it is just a matter of removing the existing duplicates. entries) 

 h3. +fix+ 

 h3. -check staging tables- 

 p(. _the duplication is not in the source data or the staging tables, as VegBank/CVS themselves have only one entry for this:_ 

 * VegBank: using @aggregate_organism_observation_id = 937165@ from those two rows: 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM "VegBank".taxonimportance WHERE taxonimportance_id = 937165; -- 1 row 
 SELECT * FROM "VegBank".taxoninterpretation WHERE taxonobservation_id = 697934; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 
 * CVS: using @aggregate_organism_observation_id = 396239@ from two rows that have this problem: 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM "CVS"."taxonImportance" WHERE "taxonImportance_ID" = 396239; -- 1 row 
 SELECT * FROM "CVS"."taxonObservation_" WHERE "taxonOccurrenceID__overall_plot" = 162259; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 h3. check normalized DB 

 p(. go through all of the tables used by view_full_occurrence_individual_view (below), and figure out if any of them have duplication. those that have duplication will cause the corresponding @LEFT JOIN@ to add duplicated rows. 

 p(. _using the example CVS row above:_ 

 p((. @FROM source@ 
 @JOIN location USING (source_id)@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN locationevent USING (location_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM locationevent WHERE locationevent_id = 912711; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN place USING (place_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN location parent_location ON parent_location.location_id = location.parent_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN coordinates USING (coordinates_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN geoscrub.geoscrub_output ON ARRAY[geoscrub_output."decimalLatitude"] = ARRAY[coordinates.latitude_deg] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output."decimalLongitude"] = ARRAY[coordinates.longitude_deg] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output.country] = ARRAY[place.country] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output."stateProvince"] = ARRAY[place.stateprovince] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output.county] = ARRAY[place.county]@ 
 @LEFT JOIN "newWorld".iso_code_gadm ON iso_code_gadm."*GADM country" = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedCountry", place.country)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN "newWorld"."newWorldCountries" ON "newWorldCountries"."*isoCode" = iso_code_gadm."*2-digit iso code"@ 
 @LEFT JOIN geoscrub.county_centroids ON place.country = 'United States'::text AND county_centroids."stateProvince" = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedStateProvince", place.stateprovince) AND county_centroids.county = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedCounty", place.county)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN locationevent parent_event ON parent_event.locationevent_id = locationevent.parent_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN project ON project.project_id = COALESCE(locationevent.project_id, parent_event.project_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN stratum ON stratum.stratum_id = COALESCE(locationevent.stratum_id, parent_event.stratum_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN method ON method.method_id = COALESCE(locationevent.method_id, parent_event.method_id);@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN taxonoccurrence ON taxonoccurrence.locationevent_id = "plot.**".locationevent_id@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM taxonoccurrence WHERE taxonoccurrence_id = 11298823; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN party collector ON collector.party_id = taxonoccurrence.collector_id@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN aggregateoccurrence USING (taxonoccurrence_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM aggregateoccurrence WHERE aggregateoccurrence_id = 11292621; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. -@LEFT JOIN plantobservation USING (aggregateoccurrence_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM plantobservation WHERE plantobservation_id = 11865135; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN specimenreplicate USING (plantobservation_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN sourcelist ON sourcelist.sourcelist_id = specimenreplicate.duplicate_institutions_sourcelist_id@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN taxondetermination ON taxondetermination.taxonoccurrence_id = taxonoccurrence.taxonoccurrence_id AND taxondetermination.iscurrent@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM taxondetermination WHERE taxonoccurrence_id = 11298823; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN party identifiedby ON identifiedby.party_id = taxondetermination.party_id@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN taxonverbatim USING (taxonverbatim_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM taxonverbatim WHERE taxonverbatim_id = 830666; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. -@LEFT JOIN taxonlabel USING (taxonlabel_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM taxonlabel WHERE taxonlabel_id = 1534892; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. *bug here:* 
 -@LEFT JOIN "TNRS".taxon_scrub ON taxon_scrub."*Name_submitted" = taxonlabel.taxonomicname@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM "TNRS".taxon_scrub WHERE "*Name_submitted" = 'Grossulariaceae Ribes rotundifolium Michx.'; -- 2 rows 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN family_higher_plant_group ON family_higher_plant_group.family = taxon_scrub."[scrubbed_]family~(-Accepted_-)__@TNRS__@vegpath.org"@ 
 @LEFT JOIN cultivated_family_locations ON cultivated_family_locations.family = taxon_scrub."[scrubbed_]family~(-Accepted_-)__@TNRS__@vegpath.org" AND cultivated_family_locations.country = "plot.**".country;@ 

 p(. _using the example VegBank row above:_ 

 p((. @FROM source@ 
 @JOIN location USING (source_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN locationevent USING (location_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN place USING (place_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN location parent_location ON parent_location.location_id = location.parent_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN coordinates USING (coordinates_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN geoscrub.geoscrub_output ON ARRAY[geoscrub_output."decimalLatitude"] = ARRAY[coordinates.latitude_deg] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output."decimalLongitude"] = ARRAY[coordinates.longitude_deg] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output.country] = ARRAY[place.country] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output."stateProvince"] = ARRAY[place.stateprovince] AND ARRAY[geoscrub_output.county] = ARRAY[place.county]@ 
 @LEFT JOIN "newWorld".iso_code_gadm ON iso_code_gadm."*GADM country" = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedCountry", place.country)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN "newWorld"."newWorldCountries" ON "newWorldCountries"."*isoCode" = iso_code_gadm."*2-digit iso code"@ 
 @LEFT JOIN geoscrub.county_centroids ON place.country = 'United States'::text AND county_centroids."stateProvince" = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedStateProvince", place.stateprovince) AND county_centroids.county = COALESCE(geoscrub_output."acceptedCounty", place.county)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN locationevent parent_event ON parent_event.locationevent_id = locationevent.parent_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN project ON project.project_id = COALESCE(locationevent.project_id, parent_event.project_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN stratum ON stratum.stratum_id = COALESCE(locationevent.stratum_id, parent_event.stratum_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN method ON method.method_id = COALESCE(locationevent.method_id, parent_event.method_id);@ 
 @LEFT JOIN taxonoccurrence ON taxonoccurrence.locationevent_id = "plot.**".locationevent_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN party collector ON collector.party_id = taxonoccurrence.collector_id@ 
 -@LEFT JOIN aggregateoccurrence USING (taxonoccurrence_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM aggregateoccurrence WHERE (source_id, (COALESCE(sourceaccessioncode, '\N'::text)) COLLATE pg_catalog."default") = (38,'937165') AND sourceaccessioncode IS NOT NULL; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. -@LEFT JOIN plantobservation USING (aggregateoccurrence_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM plantobservation WHERE aggregateoccurrence_id = 3823285; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. -@LEFT JOIN specimenreplicate USING (plantobservation_id)@- _query:_ 
 <pre><code class="SQL"> 
 SELECT * FROM specimenreplicate WHERE plantobservation_id = 4462528; -- 1 row 
 </code></pre> 

 p((. @LEFT JOIN sourcelist ON sourcelist.sourcelist_id = specimenreplicate.duplicate_institutions_sourcelist_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN taxondetermination ON taxondetermination.taxonoccurrence_id = taxonoccurrence.taxonoccurrence_id AND taxondetermination.iscurrent@ 
 @LEFT JOIN party identifiedby ON identifiedby.party_id = taxondetermination.party_id@ 
 @LEFT JOIN taxonverbatim USING (taxonverbatim_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN taxonlabel USING (taxonlabel_id)@ 
 @LEFT JOIN "TNRS".taxon_scrub ON taxon_scrub."*Name_submitted" = taxonlabel.taxonomicname@ 
 @LEFT JOIN family_higher_plant_group ON family_higher_plant_group.family = taxon_scrub."[scrubbed_]family~(-Accepted_-)__@TNRS__@vegpath.org"@ 
 @LEFT JOIN cultivated_family_locations ON cultivated_family_locations.family = taxon_scrub."[scrubbed_]family~(-Accepted_-)__@TNRS__@vegpath.org" AND cultivated_family_locations.country = "plot.**".country;@

Back

Project

General

Profile

Bug #948