SALVIAS,VegBIEN:,Comments,Source,Order within table

Line,/location/locationevent/authorlocationcode,,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/plots/plot/plotName,1

PlotID,/location/locationevent/parent_id/locationevent/*_id/location/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/1,"Brad: Not sure why this is repeated? This field and plotCode, as the same as above.","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#occurrenceID","3, 0"

PlotCode,/location/locationevent/parent_id/locationevent/*_id/location/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/2,"Brad: Same as plotCode, above","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/plots/plot/plotName","3, 1"

PlotCode,/location/locationevent/parent_id/locationevent/authorlocationcode,"Brad: Same as plotCode, above","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/plots/plot/plotName","3, 1"

PlotID,/location/locationevent/parent_id/locationevent/sourceaccessioncode,"Brad: Not sure why this is repeated? This field and plotCode, as the same as above.","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#occurrenceID","3, 0"

coll_number,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/_if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]/else/aggregateoccurrence:[@merge=1]/plantobservation:[@merge=1]/specimenreplicate/catalognumber_dwc/_alt/1,Brad: Incorrect. Map instead as for voucher_string,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#catalogNumber,20

SourceVoucher,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/_if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]/else/aggregateoccurrence:[@merge=1]/plantobservation:[@merge=1]/specimenreplicate/catalognumber_dwc/_alt/2,"Brad: OMIT. This is the verbatim text, which includes both collectors name and collection number. I would use coll_number, below.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#catalogNumber,20

coll_number,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/_if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]/then/voucher/*_id/specimenreplicate/catalognumber_dwc/_alt/1,Brad: Incorrect. Map instead as for voucher_string,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#catalogNumber,20

SourceVoucher,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/_if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]/then/voucher/*_id/specimenreplicate/catalognumber_dwc/_alt/2,"Brad: OMIT. This is the verbatim text, which includes both collectors name and collection number. I would use coll_number, below.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#catalogNumber,20

NoInd,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/count,"Brad: Incorrect for VegX. This is a count of number of indiiduals for an *aggregate* observation. For VegBank, I'm not sure. Not exactly the same as stemCount. An individual tree could have 3 stems but would still only count as 1. We need to check with Bob on this.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#individualCount,25

cover_percent,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/cover,,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/attributes/attribute/ordinal/coverPercent,0

census_no,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/definedvalue[*_id/userdefined[tablename=aggregateoccurrence,userdefinedname=censusNo]]:[@fkey=tablerecord_id]/definedvalue","Brad: Assigned by SALVIAS. 1 for first plot, then 2, 3, etc. I can't recall if we even have repeat censuses in SALVIAS. Probably not.; Expanded for clarity",http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.census_no,3

intercept_cm,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/linecover,"Brad: Incorrect for VegBank This is an aggregate observation. Used in line-intercept methodology only, describes the point along centerline at which an individual intercepts the center line of the plot. Used to determin relative abundance.",http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/individualOrganismObservations/individualOrganismObservation/volumeCanopy,3

Notes,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/notes,,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#fieldNotes,54

Ind,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/authorplantcode,"Brad: Code, if any, used by the data provider to indicate an individual tree. Scope is unknown, although typically this value is unique only within plot, or sometimes only within subplot.; ""{"" sorts it with other _if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]s",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#fieldNumber,53

height_m,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/overallheight,Brad: Incorrect for VegBank. This is a measurement applied to a single tree. Check with Bob,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/individualOrganismObservations/individualOrganismObservation/height,4

PlotObsID,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/sourceaccessioncode,"Brad: Neither is correct; this is just an internal ID for table plotObservations. However, it has the important property of uniquely identifying an ""observation"", which is an individual tree, in the case of an individual observation, or a records of a species with an associated count of individuals or measurement of percent cover, in the case of aggregate observations. Not sure where to store this. Main point is that it is not part of the original data, but an auto_increment added later.; ""{"" sorts it with other _if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]s",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#occurrenceID,19

NoInd,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemcount,"Brad: Incorrect for VegX. This is a count of number of indiiduals for an *aggregate* observation. For VegBank, I'm not sure. Not exactly the same as stemCount. An individual tree could have 3 stems but would still only count as 1. We need to check with Bob on this.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#individualCount,25

canopy_form,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/definedvalue[*_id/userdefined[tablename=stemobservation,userdefinedname=canopyForm]]:[@fkey=tablerecord_id]/definedvalue",Brad: Should also be userDefined for VegBank. ,http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.stem_canopy_form,40

canopy_position,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/definedvalue[*_id/userdefined[tablename=stemobservation,userdefinedname=canopyPosition]]:[@fkey=tablerecord_id]/definedvalue",Brad: Should also be userDefined for VegBank. ,http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.stem_canopy_position,41

liana_infestation,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/definedvalue[*_id/userdefined[tablename=stemobservation,userdefinedname=lianaInfestation]]:[@fkey=tablerecord_id]/definedvalue",Brad: Should also be userDefined for VegBank. ,http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.stem_liana_infestation,42

temp_dbh,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/diameterbreastheight,Expanded for clarity,http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.stem_dbh,36

height_m,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/height,Brad: Incorrect for VegBank. This is a measurement applied to a single tree. Check with Bob,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/individualOrganismObservations/individualOrganismObservation/height,4

ht_first_branch_m,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/heightfirstbranch,Brad: Incorrect for VegBank. This is a measurement applied to a single tree. Check with Bob,http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.ht_first_branch_m,33

tag1,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/stemtag[""""/iscurrent/_alt/2=true]/tag","Brad: Another type of code, typically a number, used by the original data provider to indicate an individual tree. These are numbers on physical tags attached to the tree. Tag2 Is the same thing, only used if the first tag was lost. Obviously not a good system as it's possible a tree tag could be lost and changed more than once.; Number removed for clarity; Quotes sort it before tag2",http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.tag2,9

tag2,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/stemtag[iscurrent=true]:[../stemtag?[iscurrent/_alt/2=true]/iscurrent/_alt/1=false]/tag,"Brad: See commend for tag1. Your mapping for tag2 looks correct. Probably both values would go here, only nested, with one superceding the other.; Number replaced with named prefix for clarity",http://salvias.net/Documents/salvias_data_dictionary.html#Plot+data.tag1,8

x_position,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/xposition,"Brad: Correct for VegBank. I'm not so sure for VegX. Let's ask Nick about this. These are important, fundamental values of many tree plots, and should be accommodated within VegX.; Table added for clarity",http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/individualOrganismObservations/individualOrganismObservation/relativePlotPosition/relativeX,801

y_position,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/aggregateoccurrence/plantobservation/stemobservation/yposition,Brad: See comment above for x_position; Table added for clarity,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/individualOrganismObservations/individualOrganismObservation/relativePlotPosition/relativeY,802

Habit,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/growthform/_map:[./{T,Arbol,palm}=tree,./{H,""Hemiepífito""}=hemiepiphyte,./{L,l,""L?"",Liana}=liana,E=epiphyte,S=shrub,Hb=herb,""vine-herbaceous""=vine,graminoid=grass,rosette=forb,*=]/value","Brad: Incorrect for VegBank, correct for VegX. This is growth form (tree, shrub, herb, etc.). It is an observation of a trait.",http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=observation&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#growthform1Type,62

PlotObsID,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/1,"Brad: Neither is correct; this is just an internal ID for table plotObservations. However, it has the important property of uniquely identifying an ""observation"", which is an individual tree, in the case of an individual observation, or a records of a species with an associated count of individuals or measurement of percent cover, in the case of aggregate observations. Not sure where to store this. Main point is that it is not part of the original data, but an auto_increment added later.; ""{"" sorts it with other _if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]s",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#occurrenceID,19

Ind,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/2,"Brad: Code, if any, used by the data provider to indicate an individual tree. Scope is unknown, although typically this value is unique only within plot, or sometimes only within subplot.; ""{"" sorts it with other _if:[name=specimenreplicate_via]s",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#fieldNumber,53

OrigGenus,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/3/_name/first,,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#scientificName,134

OrigSpecies,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/sourceaccessioncode/_alt/3/_name/last,Brad: OMIT,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#scientificName,134

infra_rank_1,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=subspecies]/plantname/_name/first",,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#taxonRank","2, 151"

auth,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]:[iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=authority]/plantname",Brad: Incorrect. This is the author of the scientificName. The should be a place for this in the taxonomic name elements of VegB and VegX. Let's discuss.,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#scientificNameAuthorship","2, 153"

infra_ep_1,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]:[iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=subspecies]/plantname/_name/last",,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#infraspecificEpithet","2, 150"

Species,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]:[iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,subspecies,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=species]/plantname",,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#specificEpithet","2, 149"

Genus,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]:[iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,subspecies,species,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=genus]/plantname",,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#genus","2, 147"

Family,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=computer]:[iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,subspecies,species,genus,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=family]/plantname",,"https://projects.nceas.ucsb.edu/nceas/projects/bien/repository/raw/schemas/vegbien.sql#role.computer, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#family","2, 146"

cfaff,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=identifier]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=binomial]/plantname/_name/last","Brad: Not sure where this goes. Indicator of identification uncertainty. 'cf.'=similar to the species listed, 'aff.'=related to the species list, but not the same. You'll need to check with Bob and with Nick where these go in VegX and VegBank.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#identificationQualifier,124

cfaff,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=identifier]/taxonfit,"Brad: Not sure where this goes. Indicator of identification uncertainty. 'cf.'=similar to the species listed, 'aff.'=related to the species list, but not the same. You'll need to check with Bob and with Nick where these go in VegX and VegBank.",http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#identificationQualifier,124

OrigGenus,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=identifier]:[isoriginal=true,iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=binomial]/plantname/_name/first/_name/first",,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#scientificName,134

OrigSpecies,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=identifier]:[isoriginal=true,iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=binomial]/plantname/_name/first/_name/last",Brad: OMIT,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#scientificName,134

OrigFamily,"/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/taxondetermination[role=identifier]:[isoriginal=true,iscurrent=true]/*_id/plantconcept/plantname_id/_simplifyPath:[next=""parent_id/plantname"",require=plantname]/path/_forEach:[in:[binomial,authority,subspecies,species,genus,],do=""plantname[rank=_val]/parent_id""]/plantname[rank=family]/plantname",Brad: OMIT,http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#family,146

coll_firstname,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/verbatimcollectorname/_name/first,Brad: See comment above,"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#recordedBy, http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/parties/party/individualName/givenName","23, 01"

coll_lastname,/location/locationevent/taxonoccurrence/verbatimcollectorname/_name/last,"Brad: Correct for VegBank. This is the collector of a separate specimen which vouchers this tree or species. I worry that vouchers are not properly accommodated in VegX. Again, we need to check with Nick.","http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#recordedBy, http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/parties/party/individualName/surName","23, 02"

PlotID,/location/sourceaccessioncode/_merge/1/_alt/1,"Brad: Not sure why this is repeated? This field and plotCode, as the same as above.","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/#occurrenceID","3, 0"

PlotCode,/location/sourceaccessioncode/_merge/1/_alt/2,"Brad: Same as plotCode, above","http://vegbank.org/vegbank/views/dba_tabledescription_detail.jsp?view=detail&wparam=plot&entity=dba_tabledescription&where=where_tablename#PARENT_ID, http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/plots/plot/plotName","3, 1"

Line,/location/sourceaccessioncode/_merge/2/_alt/2,,http://wiki.tdwg.org/twiki/pub/Vegetation/WebHome/VegX_Schema_1.5.3_proposed.zip#/veg.xsd#/plots/plot/plotName,1

IsMorpho,,** No input mapping for IsMorpho **

OrigAuth,,** No input mapping for OrigAuth **

OrigRecordID,,** No input mapping for OrigRecordID **

SpAuthStatus,,** No input mapping for SpAuthStatus **

coll_inits,,** No input mapping for coll_inits **

det_by,,** No input mapping for det_by **

dist,,** No input mapping for dist **

gen_status,,Brad: OMIT. This will be determined later by using TNRS.

height_m_commercial,,** No input mapping for height_m_commercial **

morphocf,,** No input mapping for morphocf **

morphoname,,** No input mapping for morphoname **

perp_dist,,** No input mapping for perp_dist **

phenology,,** No input mapping for phenology **

species_code,,** No input mapping for species_code **

temp_liandbh,,** No input mapping for temp_liandbh **

tmp_del,,** No input mapping for tmp_del **